July 12, 2021

Pina Colada Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches

Prep Time: 20 mins
Cook Time: 20 mins
Skip to recipe
post featured image

A tropical baked treat that's sure to transport you to the nearest beach! These pina colada cookie ice cream sandwiches are full of coconut and pineapple flavors and filled with vanilla ice cream. Coat the cookies with coconut flakes and top with a cherry and you've got a real treat!

Love ice cream filled desserts? Me too! Try this Spiced Rum Mango Cobbler No Churn Ice Cream and Blueberry Cobbler Ice Cream Bars!

pina colada ice cream sandwiches in a stack

With the baby on the way, I've been enjoying my fair share of mocktails. I'm finding that I'm enjoying mocktails more than actual drinks. Recently, I made a virgin pina colada and wow - it was SO good. Creamy, coconut-y, pineapple-y. All of the things. So, I experimented and decided that I'd turn a pina colada into an ice cream cookie sandwich.

Needless to say, it worked out. Exceptionally well. Get your ingredients together and bake up these pina colada cookie ice cream sandwiches.

Pina Colada Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches laid out on a table

what is a pina colada?

A pina colada is a Puerto Rican drink that has coconut cream, heavy cream, pineapples, rum, and ice. It's creamy and velvety and has been one of my favorite summer drinks for quite some time. Pina Coladas are the national drink of Puerto Rico and is served cold after blending all of the ingredients together and garnishing with a cherry on top!

Pina Colada Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches laid out on a table

So, the cookie itself is akin to a sugar cookie. Buttery, sweet, and soft. However, it has the addition of coconut flavoring and crushed pineapples. I was tempted to add cherries to the cookies, but decided against it because the color would've been weird. And let's be clear, we eat with our eyes first.

Bake those pina colada cookies in the oven and wait as the smell fills your kitchen! Fill the pina colada cookies with vanilla ice cream (or any ice cream of your choice) and make a big ol cookie sandwich. Toss in coconut flakes and top with a cherry and you've got a beautiful tropical baked treat that's perfect for enjoying by the poolside.

Pina Colada Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches laid out on a table

what you'll need to make this tropical treat

For starters, you'll need some coconut flavoring - which is pretty easy to find. You can order it off amazon if your local grocer doesn't carry it. You'll also need a few staples:

  • crushed pineapples (canned)
  • a few basic ingredients like butter, sugar, flour
  • baking powder
  • ice cream
  • coconut flakes
  • vanilla ice cream
  • Rum, optional
Pina Colada Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches laid out on a table

First we're going to make the pina colada cookies. Beat butter and sugar together and then add all of the wet ingredients. Mix together thoroughly. Then combine your dry ingredients and whisk together and add to your wet ingredients.

Spoon about 2 tablespoons of the cookie dough onto a baking sheet and form each cookie into a round disc. Bake for 15-18 minutes at 350 degrees F. Let the cookies cool completely before adding the ice cream or else the ice cream will melt.

If you'd like to take this a step further, you can add rum to vanilla ice cream. Now of course I didn't do this as I'm pregnant. However, I did add rum to my Husband's pina colada cookie ice cream sandwich and he loved it. Especially with the cherry on top. To do this, all you have to do is add about 2 tbsps of rum to softened ice cream, mix together and add back to the freezer to solidify.

Once the cookies have cooled completely, spoon ice cream onto one of the cookies and smash another cookie on top to make a sandwich. and you're done. It's pretty simple. Super simple actually!

more summer recipes you'll love

HAVE WE CONNECTED ON SOCIAL MEDIA? IF NOT, MAKE SURE TO FOLLOW ME ON PINTERESTFACEBOOK, AND INSTAGRAM!

Let's stay connected on social media and continue to cook together! Also, if you decide to make this recipe, please leave a star rating in the recipe card and leave a comment below! I hope that you love this recipe as much as we do!

The recipe and blog post for this Pina Colada Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches was made in partnership with Minerva Dairy! I received compensation in exchange for this work. My opinions on their butter is genuine. If I didn't love their products, I would certainly mention it! Thanks for your continued support!

Pina Colada Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches laid out on a table

Pina Colada Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches

A tropical baked treat that's sure to transport you to the nearest beach! These pina colada cookie ice cream sandwiches are full of coconut and pineapple flavors and filled with vanilla ice cream.
Serving: 6 servings
Prep Time: 20 mins
Cook Time: 20 mins
Calories: 574kcal

Ingredients

  • 1 cup Salted Butter, room temperature
  • 1 ¼ cup Sugar
  • 2 eggs
  • 1 tbsp coconut flavoring/extract
  • ½ cup Coconut Flakes
  • ½ cup crushed pineapples, drained
  • 3 cups All-Purpose Flour
  • ½ tsp Kosher Salt
  • 2 tsp Baking Powder
  • Additional Coconut flakes for garnish
  • Vanilla Ice Cream
  • 2 tbsps Rum, optional

Directions

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Combine room temperature butter and sugar in a bowl and beat together for about 1 minute, until fluffy. Add eggs, one at a time. Continue to coconut extract, coconut flakes, and drained crushed pineapples .
  • In a separate bowl, whisk together flour, salt, and baking powder. Add to wet ingredients and fold together until batter is smooth and flour is fully incorporated.
  • Scoop 2-3 tbsp balls of cookie dough onto a cookie sheet and shape into flat round discs. Bake for 18-20 minutes. Allow cookies to cool completely on a cooling rack.
  • Optional - add 2-3 tbsps rum to about 3 cups of slightly softened ice cream and mix together. Freeze until ice cream hardens again.
  • Once cookies have been cooled, scoop ice cream onto a cookie (amount as desired) and press another cookie on top. Roll sides of cookie in coconut flakes to garnish.

Nutrition

Calories: 574kcal
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American, Puerto Rican-inspired

Did you make this?

instagram icon

Tag us on the gram @britneybreaksbread to be featured in our stories!

Rate + Review

What do you think of this recipe?

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating