4 Cheese Mac and Cheese

This creamy four cheese baked mac and cheese is the BEST Old Fashioned Baked Macaroni and Cheese you’ll ever have! It’s easy to make and comes together in under an hour. If you love a cheesy, easy, and incredibly flavorful mac and cheese, this recipe is for you!

Looking for some more soul food and comfort food recipes? Check out my Smoked Gouda Mac and Cheese, Old Fashioned Candied Sweet Potatoes and my Grandma’s Buttermilk Cornbread!

Prepare to have the best mac and cheese of your life where velvety, gooey cheese coats tender macaroni! As you break through the crispy top layer, the aroma of melted cheese dances in the air, teasing your senses and making your mouth water in anticipation.

I’ve been keeping this recipe in my back pocket for a rainy day. It’s a classic southern baked mac and cheese recipe that’s been in my family for years. (Thanks mom!) It’s got the perfect combination 4 types of cheese and is easily one of my favorite recipes!

Not only is this creamy baked mac and cheese recipe super simple to make but it’s is perfect for any special occasion or holiday! Four cheese mac it’s a great side dish and can easily double as a main course at the same time.

Can we just have a moment of appreciation for the versatility of classic homemade mac and cheese? 

So, whether you’re looking for a simple recipe, comforting side dish, a crowd-pleasing main course, or an indulgent late-night snack, let macaroni and cheese be your ultimate comfort food companion. Let its melty, cheesy embrace bring you warmth and joy, as you savor the simple yet extraordinary pleasure of this timeless classic no matter the time of the year. 

Key Ingredients

The best part about this easy recipe is that it only requires a few simple ingredients. No need to make a cheese sauce, no velveeta cheese, just combine everything and bake it up!

• Elbow macaroni: I like using elbow or cavatappi noodles for an old fashioned macaroni. The cheese hugs every curve! However, any short cut pasta works.
• Heavy cream and Whole Milk: these two star ingredients mix together and make this mac creamy and rich. As the cheese melts in the oven and everything comes together, it forms its own cheesy sauce in the baking dish to make each spoonful decadent and cheesy.
• Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese: for that zingy, classic cheese flavor that we all love! If you prefer a less cheesy taste, you can use mild cheddar cheese instead.
• Asiago Cheese: it’s one of my personal favorites. While not particularly an “old fashioned” cheese, it adds a nutty yet creamy flavor to this easy baked mac. You can use parmesan cheese if you’re unable to find asiago.
• Colby Jack Cheese: for smooth yet tangy flavor. Arguably one of the best cheeses for mac and cheese.
• Mozzarella Cheese: for the epic cheese pull. You can also use fontina cheese too!
• Cream Cheese: cream cheese brings together all of that cheesy goodness! This makes it a super creamy mac!
• Seasonings: Thyme, Onion Powder, Garlic Powder, Ground Mustard, Cayenne Pepper, Nutmeg, Salt and Black Pepper

Tips for Making the Best Macaroni and Cheese

• Grate your own cheese! Use a block of cheese and shred the cheese with a grater. Pre-grated cheese is drier and tend to have additives to prevent the cheese from clumping. This may seem like a minuscule step but it makes the world of a difference!
• Don’t overcook your pasta! Only cook pasta until it’s al dente. If you cook the pasta as per normal, it’ll be too soggy when you bake it in the oven!
• If you want a crispy top, broil the macaroni and cheese for about 2-3 minutes once it’s done baking in the oven. The crispy top give it a really nice crust!
• Salt your pasta water! This enhances the flavor of the pasta! Also, do not rinse your pasta while draining. You want to keep all of the flavor in! 
• Adjust the amount of salt as per your preference. Taste as your go and add salt as needed. Cheese is naturally salty so be mindful of this!

How to make Baked Mac and Cheese

• Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Then cook macaroni/elbow pasta until according to package directions until it’s al dente. Drain and set aside.

• Grate the cheeses, add to a large bowl and mix them together. Pour heavy cream, milk, and seasonings into the cheese mixture and mix together. (Image #1)

• Add cooked macaroni to a 9×13 baking dish and pour cheese mixture on top. Add cream cheese and sour cream to the macaroni mixture and mix together again (I use my hands). Sprinkle any leftover cheese and paprika (for color) on top on top and then bake for 35 minutes. Broil for 2-3 minutes for a crunchy topping. (Image #2)

That’s it. No, really, it’s THAT simple. Baked Southern Mac and Cheese in under an hour?! Yes. Get ready for an EPIC cheese pull too.

Variations

• Make it spicy! Add a little red pepper, jalapenos, and/or hot sauce for a nice kick of spice! You can also add pepper jack for a little heat too.
• Add a protein – add bacon, pulled pork, or even your favorite seafood.
• Add breadcrumbs – Use panko breadcrumbs and make a crunchy topping for this simple mac. Some people even top their mac with ritz crackers.
• Gluten Free option – use your favorite gluten free noodles for a gluten free dish.
• Mix up the cheeses – try. adding smoked gouda cheese for a touch of smoky flavor. American cheese and monterey jack are also delicious cheeses to add to this recipe as well.

What to Serve with Mac and Cheese

4-cheese mac is a versatile dish that can be enjoyed on its own or paired with a variety of delicious accompaniments to create a well-rounded meal. Here are some suggestions for what to eat with mac and cheese:

• Brioche Dinner Rolls
• Candied Yams
• Seafood Boil
• Brussels Sprouts
• Low Country Boil
• Salmon New Orleans
• Collard Greens

Storing, Freezing, and Reheating

Storing: This mac and cheese recipe is best stored in the refrigerator in an airtight container for up to 5 days – that is of course if it even lasts that long. I’m telling you, everyone will be devouring this recipe!

Freezing: To freeze it, add to an airtight container that’s freezer safe and store for up to 3 months. When you’re ready to eat it again, let it thaw completely and heat in the microwave or stovetop in a large saucepan. 

Reheating: If heating on the stovetop, as it warms, you can add a little bit of milk for added creaminess to give it that “fresh out of the oven” taste.

More Soul Food Recipes

Thanksgiving

Slow Cooker Collard Greens

Desserts

Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

Thanksgiving

Sweet Potato Cornbread

Main Course

Fried Cabbage with Onions and Bacon

Recipe FAQs